Lack of security guard rules could expose GN, professor says

Nunavut is one of just two Canadian jurisdictions without a law regulating private security industry

Justice Minister George Hickes addresses the legislative assembly earlier this year. Before he joined cabinet, Hickes called on the government to regulate the private security industry. (File photo by Daron Letts)

By Daron Letts

The Government of Nunavut could be sued if unregulated private security guards in the territory break the law, says a criminologist, who studies surveillance and security regulation.

That’s because Nunavut has no legislation that governs the training and certification of security guards.

“What are they waiting for? I don’t understand the rationale for not pursuing it and passing it into law,” University of Windsor professor Randy Lippert said in a phone interview.

The government does not appear to share that sense of urgency.

It has received calls to enact regulation during sessions of the legislative assembly in 2018, 2023 and 2025.

The latest call for regulation came from current Justice Minister George Hickes during the winter 2025 sitting of the legislative assembly, about 10 months before he joined cabinet.

He also highlighted the need for Nunavummiut to be hired in security roles.

“I want to encourage all entities of the government to consider working together on setting the stage of bringing forward legislation in the next government,” Hickes said as a regular MLA on Feb. 26, 2025, about nine months before he became a cabinet minister.

Last week, however, he declined to comment on the issue.

Justice Department spokesperson Stephen Shaddock said in an email earlier this month that the department “is monitoring regulatory approaches in other Canadian jurisdictions.”

“However, there is no specific timeline for considering similar legislation in Nunavut.”

The Northwest Territories is the only other jurisdiction in Canada that does not regulate the private security industry.

But in Ontario, for example, the Private Security and Investigative Services Act requires companies to ensure guards have and maintain a valid agency licence. If security guards employed by the agency are charged for working without a valid licence, their employer may also face charges.

The licencing process includes a criminal records check and completion of mandatory basic training, which is at least 40 hours.

Ontario’s law allows people to submit complaints in instances where they believe a guard violated the act. The solicitor general’s office reviews those complaints.

Iqaluit’s Northern store recently ramped up its security to include guards in tactical uniforms equipped with body cameras and what appear to be retractable batons.

The North West Co., the Winnipeg-based parent company of Northern, contracts the guards through Iqaluit-based Canadian Arctic Protective Services.

In an email earlier this month, the security company’s regional director, Paul Hunter, declined to say whether the device that the guards carry is a baton.

A supervisor with Canadian Arctic Protective Services stands at the exit of Iqaluit’s Northern store with a body-worn camera in October. A University of Windsor professor warns the Government of Nunavut could be civilly liable if a security guard breaks the law because the territory is one of two Canadian jurisdictions without a law regulating the private security industry. (File phot Daron Letts)

Retractable batons and other instruments that may be used as weapons are regulated under the Criminal Code, said Shaddock.

“Organizations should ensure that equipment carried by employees complies with the law, as non-compliance may result in criminal charges and potential civil liability,” he said.

Lippert said that liability could extend to the government itself.

“If something bad happens, it seems like a lot of people are going to get sued, and it may well include the government,” he said.

When asked about Lippert’s warning, the Justice Department’s spokesperson said the department would not comment on “a hypothetical scenario.”

“In all instances where the Government of Nunavut is served with a lawsuit, the government will review the matter on its merits and respond accordingly,” Shaddock said in an email.

Share This Story

(0) Comments

Join the Conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*